Serious concerns about VPNArea

Shadow:_trusted_user::_male:Posted at 2020-02-11 13:18:13(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Reppoints: 5
Posts: 28
Uploads: 746

I checked their pricing and seems like they are generally way cheaper than other VPNs around but the thing which is contradicting Torrentgalaxy and their TOS is suspicious to me

Can someone from their customer support confirm/deny those statements before I and probably others purchase their VPN?

PS: I don't generally trust any VPN (Including NordVPN, ExpressVPN, PIA, etc. ) to have zero log privacy. As in real time all those dedicated servers which they use for their VPN have current access logs which are mess, but if someone with enough tech knowledge can access them, they can pin-point those and track the real users behind them.
But the only concern here is about suspending your account for torrenting.

Torrentalaxy:
Torrent friendly
Unlimited P2P bandwidth

VPNArea:

Quote:

12. Copyright Protected Materials
Offshore Security EOOD (VPN Area) respects the intellectual property rights of others and expects that you do the same. We may suspend your account if it can be proven that you committed any copyrights infringement. You may not upload, download, post, publish, transmit, reproduce, or distribute in any way, files, material, information, software or other material obtained through the System that is protected by copyright or other proprietary right or derivative works with respect thereto, without obtaining permission of the copyright owner or other right holder. Additionally, you shall not upload, download, post, publish, reproduce, transmit or distribute in any way any component of the System itself or derivative works with respect thereto.
Basically saying they will suspend your account if some company files DMCA takedown against IP address from their VPN.

Torrentalaxy:
No logs!
Strict zero logs policy

VPNArea:

Quote:

◦If Offshore Security EOOD (VPN Area) determines that you have posted one or more articles of spam, we may cancel your account immediately and take steps to prevent you from using our network at any time thereafter.
How they can know if I posted some spam article? To determine someone's usage pattern they have to //
log every single user with timestamp
real ip address
server to which you are connected on their vpn
your account id on their vpn
and every url you have visited with query string. (eg site.com/submit/article/43245235/)
then filter your IP and see how you used their VPN.

This is like complete tracking.  Even if they have to keep logs due to Bulgaria being part of European Union, they shouldn't suspend their users for things they promote. It's really unfair to give them 88$ and get yourself suspended for false claims.


Last edited by Shadow on 2020-02-11 13:56:39


 
Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, zeke23:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_sun:
battlestar:_trusted_uploader::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_junkie:Posted at 2020-02-11 14:20:26(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Reppoints: 852
Posts: 1705
Uploads: 6812

Thats just legal mumbo jumbo that they have to put up to keep everyone happy.

Have you ever read the notification on this site ?

Quote:

We want you to know that we do not have any copyrighted or illegal content on our site.
:D

 
Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, bombegranate:_trusted_user::_junkie::_turtle:, zeke23:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_sun:, miok:_super_admin:
Shadow:_trusted_user::_male:Posted at 2020-02-11 14:32:42(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Reppoints: 5
Posts: 28
Uploads: 746

battlestar wrote:

Thats just legal mumbo jumbo that they have to put up to keep everyone happy.

Have you ever read the notification on this site ?

Quote:

We want you to know that we do not have any copyrighted or illegal content on our site.
:D
Might be true, but then it's still not nice to threat their customers with suspension.

Technically that's correct.   (Hence why piratebay doesn't adhere to copyright claims.)
Only images can be breaking law here because they are hosted and stored on torrent galaxy servers.

.torrent is just encoded metadata with pieces such as hash url / torrent size / file pieces / trackers / dht / privte/public torrent / etc. which is getting decoded inside torrent client and connects to the peers which have the same metadata inside their torrent client and share the file altogether to each other.

Basically this site is just a messenger which connects those people together, those people have the files, this site doesn't.

 
Post liked by - ezratheproto:_trusted_uploader::_female::_junkie::_kitty::_turtle:, Ange1:_moderator::_female:, zeke23:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_sun:
miok:_super_admin:Posted at 2020-02-11 14:37:45(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Master Lurker
Reppoints: 6289
Posts: 10305
Uploads: 3873

Obviously we (or any other torrent site) don't host any copyrighted material. That would be suicide.

 
Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, joeb1kenbarbie:_male:, PaladinNites:_vip::_trusted_user::_male:, sherb:_trusted_uploader::_sitefriend::_sitelover::_junkie::_kitty::_sun::_turtle:, zeke23:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_sun:, GodAndUlster:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_junkie::_sun::_turtle:
Shadow:_trusted_user::_male:Posted at 2020-02-11 14:48:33(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Reppoints: 5
Posts: 28
Uploads: 746

And foremost as people over vpn tend to abuse its service with all kind of nasty stuff and if they indeed keep logs and gets their servers seized by law enforcement (actually happened to big hosting providers all the time for botnet and nasty stuff people host) how long they store the logs for? (They explictly said to have means to find users who use their vpn for bad stuff) Because that would really screw over both good consumers and bad one as many people can connect over same IP address on the VPN.

Bulgaria is part of the EU and they have a cybercrime department. Meaning if the server with IP xxx.xxx.xxx.xxx did some very nasty shit, they will raid the datacenter and seize that server. (At this point VPNArea is powerless and can't delete logs or wipe server or anything // Even if server is encrypted, the server disk can be cloned because encryption key is still active within RAM and with physical access to the server they can clone it and get everything from the server while it's still ON and has active power supply)
Then use it to inspect and find the person who did it.
So logs there will pin point to multiple users which whre connected to that exact server and boom you get screwed because someone else did something nasty and you were unlucky to be on same server.

Last edited by Shadow on 2020-02-11 15:03:57


 
Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, GodAndUlster:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_junkie::_sun::_turtle:
joeb1kenbarbie:_male:Posted at 2020-02-11 15:12:48(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Reppoints: 49
Posts: 41
Uploads: 0

I started using PIA about 4 years ago. I got flagged a couple of times by my isp before that using a private tracker and no DHT, local peer, etc. with my client, but not a single issue since PIA. Seedbox was next on the list but all is well.

 
Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, zeke23:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_sun:
zeke23:_vip::_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_sun:Posted at 2020-02-11 15:34:43(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Reppoints: 1375
Posts: 1968
Uploads: 1449

i have used PIA also with good results till i started uploading then it was a different story, i did have a lot of help from them, i think anyone using a VPN needs to go slow and be careful when buying
there are people here that can help maybe they will jump in, good luck to you all!!

 
Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, joeb1kenbarbie:_male:
VPNAreaPROMO:_vip:Posted at 2020-02-11 15:59:56(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
Reppoints: 0
Posts: 1
Uploads: 0

These suspicions are based on a misunderstanding.
No VPN provider wants their network abused or be accused of encouraging illegal activities.
To cover bases it's common practice to disallow illegal activities.
That does not mean logs are being kept. It only means the provider will not be an accessory to whatever you might be planning to do.

This is not concerning. No logs are kept.
As example I'll show you Private Internet Access and ExpressVPN also have the same policy.

https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/pages/terms-of-service/

Quote:

CONDUCT
You agree to comply with all applicable laws and regulations in connection with use of this service. You must also agree that you and any other user that you have provided access to will not engage in any of the following activities:
  • Sending or receiving unsolicited and/or commercial emails in violation of law, promotional materials, "junk mail," "spam," "chain letters," or "pyramid schemes";
  • Exploiting, possessing, producing, receiving, transporting, or distributing any illegal content, including but not limited to any sexually explicit depiction of children;
  • Uploading, possessing, receiving, transporting, or distributing any copyrighted, trademark, or patented content which you do not own or lack written consent or a license from the copyright owner;
    ...
  • Quote:

    BREACH
    PIA abides by a ZERO TOLERANCE policy relating to any activity which breaches or violates our terms and conditions.We can disable your account if you break our rules.
    Along with the ZERO TOLERANCE policy, Clients who materially breach the terms and conditions will have their account or a subscription removed without any refund.
    ...
    https://www.expressvpn.com/tos

    Quote:

    In using our Services, you agree not to:
  • Send or transmit unsolicited advertisements or content (i.e., “spam") over the Service.
  • Send, post, or transmit over the Service any content which is illegal, hateful, threatening, insulting, or defamatory; infringes on intellectual property rights; invades privacy; or incites violence.
  • Upload, download, post, reproduce, or distribute any content protected by copyright or any other proprietary right without first having obtained permission from the owner of the proprietary content.
    ...
  • Quote:

    In order to protect the Services from being misused or used to harm someone, ExpressVPN reserves the right to take appropriate measures when our Services are being used contrary to these Terms and applicable laws. You agree that ExpressVPN may terminate your account, without providing a refund for Services already paid, if you misuse the Service.
    It's the same everywhere.
    If you have any more questions regarding this.
    Please open a ticket on the VPNArea site.
    https://vpnarea.com/front/home/contacts/

    Last edited by VPNAreaPROMO on 2020-02-11 16:02:10


     
    Post liked by - Ksenia:_admin::_female::_junkie:, Ange1:_moderator::_female:, joeb1kenbarbie:_male:
    miok:_super_admin:Posted at 2020-02-11 16:41:01(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
    Master Lurker
    Reppoints: 6289
    Posts: 10305
    Uploads: 3873

    The people trying to sell you a VPN need to post the TOS mumbo jumbo to please the powers that be and stay legal. If they had any intention of enforcing it, they wouldn't be advertising on torrent sites. Keeping activity logs is a different story. That's why "free" VPNs should be avoided. If something sounds to good to be true, it usually is. You get what you pay for and There are many more providers than there used to be, as a result, the prices have become very competitive. A reliable VPN can cost less than taking the family to the theater a couple times. A small price to pay for the peace of mind of knowing your activities are at least reasonably private.

     
    Post liked by - Balerion:_trusted_user::_sitefriend::_male::_sitelover::_sun::_turtle:, Ange1:_moderator::_female:, joeb1kenbarbie:_male:
    Shadow:_trusted_user::_male:Posted at 2020-02-11 17:58:29(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
    Reppoints: 5
    Posts: 28
    Uploads: 746

    I want to thank @VPNArea for responding here. It will probably help people to get better overview.

    ---
    Also, here's the note from @Matt, the exit node TOR operator

    For everyone: Please don't use TOR network for torrenting, that really makes you a piece of shit.

    VPN vs your ISP

    Quote:

    Yes VPNs hide everything about what you're doing on the Internet from your ISP. So does Tor (Browser). Only sophisticated attacks (e.g. website fingerprinting) allow them to determine what you're doing, and these apply to VPNs, Tor, and every other "thing" like them that actually exists off paper. Tor has taken some measures to mitigate attacks such as website fingerprinting, but I am not convinced they are effective at this time.
    VPN vs a government

    Quote:

    This is a tough one, but if you believe your government is watching your traffic between you and your ISP or can otherwise compel your ISP to tell it information about your activities, I think it is foolish to believe they cannot do the same with your chosen VPN provider. If you really believe your VPN provider wouldn't cooperate, then I bet the datacenter in which their servers reside or the upstream autonomous systems would do so, if they aren't already. This type of adversary is extremely powerful and not even Tor can totally protect you. Search terms in this space include "traffic correlation." In the name of brevity I'll stop here after saying one last thing: it doesn't matter how many hops or how much technology you have in the middle of your connection if your adversary can watch traffic sufficiently close to you and to your ultimate destination, and you should not limit yourself to an adversary model that requires them to run the hops as opposed to simply watch Internet traffic near them.


    Last edited by Shadow on 2020-02-11 18:08:52


     
    Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, joeb1kenbarbie:_male:
    bombegranate:_trusted_user::_junkie::_turtle:Posted at 2020-02-11 18:08:35(249Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
    Reppoints: 360
    Posts: 847
    Uploads: 0

    As far as i know VPNArea doesn't support Port Forwarding, which makes it a bit unsuitable for torrening IMO...

     
    Post liked by - Ange1:_moderator::_female:, miok:_super_admin:
    Gladius:_trusted_user:Posted at 2020-03-14 10:15:48(244Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
    Reppoints: 115
    Posts: 83
    Uploads: 0

    well thumb rule is dont trust anybody, if they want to hunt you they will :?:?

    Depends on your online activities though, dowloading torrent is no big deal u can just use a simple paid vpn like nord or PIA or Express etc

     
    Superbikemike:_moderator::_turtle:Posted at 2020-03-22 21:47:55(243Wks ago) Report Permalink URL 
    Reppoints: 7750
    Posts: 3545
    Uploads: 0

    Basically saying they will suspend your account if some company files DMCA takedown against IP address from their VPN.

    thats says it all....  they log your ip to there server ip and thats how they can tell .... :P